How the judges score Vale of Atholl
28 performances across 4 seasons · every sheet they've been given
Read this carefully. Each bar is a judge's average placing of Vale of Atholl minus where the band finished overall that day — left means they tend to score the band higher than it finishes, right means lower. It reflects a judge's tendency, not a verdict: piping, drumming and ensemble also carry the band's own strengths in those disciplines, and a small sample says little. For piping — the only discipline with two judges on the same tune — the vs co-judge figure is the cleaner signal. Adjudicators seen 2+ times get a bar — two-sheet reads are shown faint, since one day swings them; everyone else is listed below.
◄ scores you higherscores you lower ►
Jim Baxter
-2.0
Lee Innes
-2.0
Adrian Hoy
-1.5
Brian Martin
-1.3
Arthur Cook
-1.3
Robert Mathieson
-1.0
Jennifer Hutcheon
-0.3
vs co-judge -0.5
Cameron Edgar
≈0
vs co-judge +1.0
Ross Walker
≈0
John Connor
≈0
vs co-judge +2.5
James Campbell
+0.3
vs co-judge -0.3
Paul Brown
+0.3
James Semple
+0.3
vs co-judge -1.0
Paul Turner
+0.3
Thomas Brown
+0.5
Gordon Laurie
+0.5
vs co-judge +1.0
Gordon Brown
+1.0
Peter Snaddon
+1.0
vs co-judge -1.3
William Black
+1.3
Barry Donaldson
+1.4
vs co-judge 0.0
Peter Hunt
+1.5
vs co-judge +0.5
Donald MacPhee
+1.5
vs co-judge 0.0
John Reville
+2.0
vs co-judge +2.0
John Moles
+2.0
Maurice Rhodes
+2.0
vs co-judge +1.5
Gordon Lawrie
+2.3
William Garrett
+2.5
vs co-judge +2.5
Colin Moffett
+4.0
Mark Faloon
+5.5
vs co-judge +2.0
Also on the sheet (judged only once — too few to read a tendency)
Alec Dudgeon Anthony Sloane Brian Switalla David Brown David Hilder David Middleton Don Bradford Duncan Millar George Wilson Grant Walker Gregory Dinsdale Iain Simpson J Jorgensen John Nevans John Wilson Keith Orr Kenneth Eller M Wilson Mark Wilson Richard Parkes Robert Worrall Ronnie McShannon Stuart Coils