How the judges score Kilchoman Distillery Isle of Islay
14 performances across 3 seasons · every sheet they've been given
Read this carefully. Each bar is a judge's average placing of Kilchoman Distillery Isle of Islay minus where the band finished overall that day — left means they tend to score the band higher than it finishes, right means lower. It reflects a judge's tendency, not a verdict: piping, drumming and ensemble also carry the band's own strengths in those disciplines, and a small sample says little. For piping — the only discipline with two judges on the same tune — the vs co-judge figure is the cleaner signal. Adjudicators seen 2+ times get a bar — two-sheet reads are shown faint, since one day swings them; everyone else is listed below.
◄ scores you higherscores you lower ►
Barry Donaldson
-3.0
vs co-judge -4.0
John Reville
-2.0
vs co-judge -0.5
John Wilson
-2.0
vs co-judge -1.0
Colin Moffett
-1.0
vs co-judge -0.5
James Semple
-0.5
vs co-judge 0.0
Gordon Brown
-0.5
Alvis Kerr
≈0
vs co-judge 0.0
Robert Mathieson
≈0
William Garrett
≈0
vs co-judge +3.0
Paul Turner
+1.0
David Middleton
+1.0
vs co-judge +2.0
David Brown
+1.0
Thomas Brown
+1.0
James Campbell
+1.0
vs co-judge -1.0
Lee Innes
+1.3
Anthony Sloane
+1.5
Also on the sheet (judged only once — too few to read a tendency)
Adrian Hoy Alan Ronaldson Alec Dudgeon Allan Craig Arthur Cook Brian Switalla Cameron Edgar Donald MacPhee Gordon Lawrie Gordon Parkes Jennifer Hutcheon Jim Baxter John Moles John Nevans Mark Faloon Mark Wilson Maurice Rhodes Paul Brown Peter Snaddon Robert Worrall Terry Lee William Black